On this page ▾
Today's prices ask more of Tata Steel than of Hindalco.
At current prices, buyers of Hindalco are assuming about 0% growth against 12% in its own record; for Tata Steel it is 6% against 0%. That shows which share needs more to go right — not which is cheaper. How far each trades from its estimated fair value is in the full valuations.
- Valuation method: Hindalco on estimate withheld; Tata Steel on discounted cash flow.
- Size: the two are worth roughly the same on the stock market.
- Record: Hindalco has grown revenue faster: Hindalco compounded at about 11% a year (FY2018–FY2026) and Tata Steel at about 7% (FY2018–FY2026).
- What to watch: aluminium prices at Hindalco; indian margins at Tata Steel.
| Hindalco | Tata Steel | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | ₹923 | ₹182 |
| Market cap | ₹2.05L Cr | ₹2.27L Cr |
| P/E | 10.7 | 19.6 |
| P/B | 1.50 | 2.23 |
| Fair value 🔒 sign in | ₹0,000 | ₹0,000 |
| Upside 🔒 sign in | +00% | +00% |
| Valued on | Estimate withheld | Discounted cash flow |
01Two businesses
An aluminium giant on two continents
Hindalco Industries, the Aditya Birla group's metals company, is one of the world's largest aluminium producers. In India it mines bauxite, refines alumina and smelts aluminium using its own power, and also runs a copper smelter and refinery at Dahej.
One company, two steel businesses
Tata Steel, founded in 1907 at Jamshedpur, is one of India's two largest steelmakers. Its Indian plants — Jamshedpur, Kalinganagar and Angul, the last acquired with Bhushan Steel in 2018 — have their own iron-ore mines, which makes them among the lowest-cost producers in the world.
02The records side by side
Hindalco has grown revenue faster: Hindalco compounded at about 11% a year (FY2018–FY2026) and Tata Steel at about 7% (FY2018–FY2026). By revenue the two are of broadly similar size. Hindalco kept 4.9% of revenue as net profit in FY2026; Tata Steel kept 4.7% of revenue as net profit in FY2026. Hindalco was profitable in every year shown; Tata Steel reported a net loss in FY2024.
Full ten-year tables and charts are on each company's page: Hindalco · Tata Steel.
03What each price assumes
Work backwards from each share price and you can see what buyers are taking for granted — the rate each company must sustain to justify what it costs, against what its own record supports.
04What decides each one's value
- Aluminium pricesGlobal prices swing Indian smelting profits.
- Novelis spreadsNovelis earns a conversion margin, less exposed to metal prices.
- Indian marginsCaptive iron ore gives the Indian business a cost advantage that drives most of the value.
- European lossesEvery year Europe loses less money adds directly to group value.
05What could go wrong
- Metal price fallsWeak aluminium prices hit Indian profits.
- Novelis executionBig US projects have run over budget.
- The steel cycleSteel prices can fall sharply when global demand weakens.
- EuropeDecarbonisation costs and weak demand could keep European losses going.
06Which is better value?
Sign in free to see which trades further below its worth
- ✓Both fair values per share — each on the method that fits the business
- ✓Every step of both workings — growth, margins and cost of capital, with sources
- ✓Bull, base and bear cases — for each company
- ✓Downloadable reports — the full write-up for each, yours to keep
08Questions people ask
Is Hindalco or Tata Steel better value?
That turns on how far each share trades from its estimated fair value. Both figures, with every step of the working, are in the full valuations, free to view once you sign in. On the public numbers, Hindalco trades at 10.7 times earnings and 1.50 times book value, and Tata Steel at 19.6 times earnings and 2.23 times book value — but multiples alone mislead when two businesses work differently, which is why each is valued on the method that fits it.
What is the difference between Hindalco and Tata Steel?
Hindalco Industries, the Aditya Birla group's metals company, is one of the world's largest aluminium producers. Tata Steel, founded in 1907 at Jamshedpur, is one of India's two largest steelmakers.
Are Hindalco and Tata Steel valued the same way?
No. Hindalco is valued on estimate withheld and Tata Steel on discounted cash flow, because forcing one model onto both would misstate at least one of them.
What does today's price assume for Hindalco and Tata Steel?
Worked backwards from the share price, Hindalco needs about 0% growth and Tata Steel about 6% growth, against 12% and 0% in their own records.